Five months after Flavia Laun moved into her home in Churchill, the Woodland Hills School District appealed her assessment. According to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, the appeal raised her tax bill by more than 10%. She later sued Allegheny County. On August 17, 2026, in Flavia E. Laun vs. Allegheny County, Judge Kenneth G. Valasek ordered the first countywide reassessment since the 2012 base year.
Her case started on another side of Allegheny County, which also includes Marshall Township.
The figure on the listing comes from a 2012 base
Allegheny County, Marshall Township and the North Allegheny School District have separate millage rates. Allegheny County explains that one mill equals 0.001 of assessed value. These are the rates for 2026:
| Taxing body | 2026 millage |
|---|---|
| Allegheny County | 6.4300 |
| Marshall Township | 1.4200 |
| North Allegheny School District | 20.4309 |
| Combined | 28.2809 |
The county and township rates come from the Allegheny County Treasurer's municipal millage table. The school rate comes from the Treasurer's school district table. For 2026-27, North Allegheny also lists a $243.91 homestead credit on school taxes for qualified owner-occupants.
The assessed value those rates apply to is the figure that can change after a sale. Pennsylvania's State Tax Equalization Board certifies a Common Level Ratio for each county, which compares assessed values with what homes actually sell for. Allegheny County's ratio is 49.3% for July 1, 2026 through June 30, 2027, down from 50.14% the year before.
Sale prices and assessment appeals
The ratio matters in assessment appeals. PublicSource describes the Common Level Ratio as the factor appeals use to relate a sale price or current market value to an assessed value.
The Post-Gazette reported in February 2026 that school districts and municipalities often file appeals against recently sold properties. Because the sale price can show how much a home's value has risen since the last reassessment, the paper reported that new homeowners can see tax increases soon after moving in, a pattern it said has been called "the newcomers tax." The same report said more than 20,000 Allegheny County homeowners faced appeals from taxing bodies over the preceding four years.
The law on choosing which homes to appeal is still developing. On May 19, 2026, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled in a Chester County case brought against the Downingtown Area School District. The court held that choosing appeals by a neutral monetary threshold does not, without more, violate the state constitution's Uniformity Clause. A footnote says the opinion does not address whether "recently sold" is a prohibited subclass. The full opinion leaves that question for another case.
What the August order changes
According to Allegheny County's announcement, Judge Valasek's order sets these terms:
- The county must perform a reassessment to replace the current 2012 base values.
- A special master will be appointed to preside over the reassessment.
- The work must start by 2027 and be finished within five years.
- After this reassessment, the judge directed countywide reassessments every five years.
County Executive Sara Innamorato said in that release that the county "will comply in a professional manner" and that regular reassessments "will be an improvement over the current ad hoc approach."
Reassessment and tax revenue
The Allegheny County Controller's office says a 2005 county ordinance bars the county itself from collecting any windfall from a reassessment.
Beaver County's court-ordered reassessment, the first since 1982, produced new tax bills in January 2024. Its chief assessor told The Center Square, in a story the Butler Eagle ran, that total assessed value rose from $2 billion to $15 billion while the millage rate fell from 26 to 3.67. Some owners paid less even though their assessments rose 60% or 70%.
The 49.3% ratio is a tool for appeals. It does not set the new values, which the order says will replace the 2012 base. Because every property is revalued at once, assessments that have drifted apart since 2012 move back toward a common footing. The Supreme Court made the same point about appeals, writing that bringing an outlier in line with the ratio "enhances fairness to the remaining taxpayers."
The relief program is built for long-term owners
Allegheny County Council passed a Longtime Owner-Occupant ordinance on February 10, 2026. It does not take effect until the tax rolls reflect a countywide reassessment. The ordinance text describes a program that phases in an increase for qualifying owners.
Across the county line in Cranberry
Buyers comparing Marshall with Cranberry Township are looking at a different system. The Butler Eagle reported in March 2026 that Butler County last reassessed in 1969 and that no timeline had been set for a new one. Butler's certified Common Level Ratio for July 2026 through June 2027 is 6.0%. Assessed values and millage on the two sides of the line are built on very different bases. Comparing the two areas' millage directly tells you little.
The reassessment timeline
When will the new values show up on tax bills? The order requires the reassessment to start by 2027 and be finished within five years. The county's announcement does not name the first tax year for the new values.
This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Please confirm how these rules apply to your own purchase with a tax professional or attorney.